The 2005 MTV Movie Awards (2005): Breakthrough Female for "The Day After Tomorrow"
26th Annual Young Artist Awards (2005): Best Performance in a Feature Film - Leading Young Actress for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films (2005): Best Performance by a Younger Actor for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Online Film Critics Society Awards (2005): Best Breakthrough Performance for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Satellite Awards (2005): Best Actress in a Motion Picture, Comedy or Musical for "The Phantom of the Operah"
10th Annual Critics Choice Awards (2005): Best Young Actress for "The Phantom of the Operah"
The 2005 Golden Globe Awards (2005): Best Performance by an Actress in a Motion Picture - Musical or Comedy for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Moviefone Moviegoer Awards (2005): Hottest Rising Star for "The Phantom of the Operah"
The 2005 Saturn Awards (2005): Best Performance By A Younger Actor for "The Phantom of the Operah"
National Board of Review Awards (2004): Best Breakthrough Performance by an Actress for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Sundance Film Festival - Special Jury Price (2001): Outstanding Ensemble Performance for "Songcatcher"
Independent Spirit Awards (2001): Best Debut Performance for "Songcatcher"
21st Annual Young Artist Awards (2000): Best Performance in a TV Movie or Pilot - Supporting Young Actress for "Genius"

26th Annual Young Artist Awards (2005): Best Performance in a Feature Film - Leading Young Actress for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Online Film Critics Society Awards (2005): Best Breakthrough Performance for "The Phantom of the Operah"
10th Annual Critics Choice Awards (2005): Best Young Actress for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Moviefone Moviegoer Awards (2005): Hottest Rising Star for "The Phantom of the Operah"
The 2005 Saturn Awards (2005): Best Performance By A Younger Actor for "The Phantom of the Operah"
National Board of Review Awards (2004): Best Breakthrough Performance by an Actress for "The Phantom of the Operah"
Sundance Film Festival - Special Jury Price (2001): Outstanding Ensemble Performance for "Songcatcher"